D. Differences between REST and GraphQL To conclude, we summarize the key differences between REST and GraphQL. Bei der JavaScript-Bibliothek GraphQL.js nutzen Sie dafür den JavaScript-Paketmanager npm (Node Package Manager) und folgenden Befehl: Alternativ können Sie die Bibliothek auch über den unter anderem von Facebook (überwiegend) und Google entwickelten Paket- und Abhängigkeitsmanager Yarn beziehen: Voraussetzung ist in beiden Fällen natürlich, dass eine aktuelle Version von Node.js installiert ist (empfohlen: Node v6.0.0 oder höher). GraphQL is often touted as an alternative to REST APIs. 2015 machte Facebook den GraphQL-Quellcode frei verfügbar – zu diesem Zeitpunkt regelte er fast schon den gesamten Datenzugriff der mobilen Apps. HTTP status codes. Each resource is identified by a URL, and you retrieve that resource by sending a GETrequest to that URL. GraphQL is the better REST Over the past decade, REST has become the standard (yet a fuzzy one) for designing web APIs. GraphQL has been around for five years but quite frequently it still is seen as “the new kid on the block.” When it comes to deciding if and when to choose GraphQL for an API, this decision is often framed as a choice between “GraphQL and REST.” REST in this comparison stands for resource-oriented HTTP-based APIs. #002 REST vs GraphQL with Ben Wilson. Over the past decade, REST has become the standard (yet a fuzzy one) for designing web APIs. Was hinter diesem Akronym steckt und warum genau HATEOAS für REST so... Für viele IT-Bereiche ist es notwendig, dass die Kommunikation zwischen verschiedenen Anwendungen schnell und fehlerfrei funktioniert. Im direkten Vergleich „GraphQL vs. REST“ erweist sich das Abfragekonzept von Facebook als wesentlich präziser und effizienter, was der Performance Ihrer Applikation zugutekommt. Practical Tutorial Choosing the right tutorial . Das ist auch einer der großen Vorzüge bei der Implementierung einer GraphQL-Schnittstellein Ihre App. GraphQL can speed up development and automation in comparison to REST. Let's just do a quick recap regarding the differences between REST and GraphQL: GraphQL solves both over-fetching and under-fetching issues by allowing the client to request only the needed data; Since the client now has more freedom in the fetched data, development is much faster with GraphQL than what it would be with REST. The main GraphQL quality is being less loquacious than traditional REST API. Please advise. Let’s step through a practical example to compare GraphQL vs REST and see the similarities and differences of both API design architectures. Öffnen Sie dazu einfach Ihren Browser und geben Sie die folgende Adresse ein: Nachdem Sie in den verschiedenen Schritten dieses GraphQL-Tutorials die notwendigen Komponenten installiert, Ihr erstes Abfrage-Schema erstellt und den eigenen Server gestartet haben, können Sie sich danach also in aller Ruhe mit den Query-Eingabemöglichkeiten vertraut machen. GraphQL vs. REST. GraphQL is a Query Language; REST is not. GraphQL and REST APIs send data in different ways. While REST is built on top of an existing architecture, which in the most common scenarios is HTTP, GraphQL on the other hand is building its own set of conventions. Ohne eigene Homepage kommt fast kein Unternehmen mehr aus. Benefits of GraphQL. Which of them is overrated? It’s a runtime for executing queries against data, and Facebook open-sourced it in 2015. In contrast, GraphQL lets a developer create dynamic data based on the view’s requirements and only call what’s needed.The query is based on an understanding of how data is structured. In terms of GraphQL vs. REST security, the credit seems to be leaning towards the latter’s side. Seit 2017 läuft das Projekt unter der freien OWFa-1.0-Lizenz (Open Web Foundation). GraphQL vs. REST – Was unterscheidet die beiden API-Konzepte? As each client specifies exactly what information it’s interested in, it is possible to gain a deep understanding of how the available data is being used. Using GraphQL, the client can specify exactly the data it needs in a. of the server’s response follows precisely the nested structure defined in the query. In some scenarios, GraphQL will indeed be a better solution, but in others, you might find that REST APIs are still preferable. Data fetching. Wie funktioniert das Advanced Message Queuing Protocol? This response however might contain more info about the users that are returned, e.g. In general, selecting GraphQL or REST is a difficult task because both are good in their way. Benefits of the GraphQL Specification RESTful APIs, including the WP REST API have no official specification. With GraphQL, you can also do low-level performance monitoring of the requests that are processed by your server. 4. Once the schema is defined, the teams working on frontend and backends can do their work without further communication since they both are aware of the definite structure of the data that’s sent over the network. Share. Damit Ihre Anwendung GraphQL-Abfragen verarbeiten kann, benötigen Sie ein Schema, das den Typ „Query“ (also Abfrage) definiert sowie den Zugangspunkt zu Ihrer Schnittstelle (auch API-Root genannt) inklusive Resolver-Funktion. that returns a list of followers per user. Wer sich mit GraphQL auseinandersetzt, der wird beispielsweise schnell feststellen, dass erhaltene Antworten eins zu eins die gestellten Abfragen widerspiegeln. Practical Example of GraphQL vs REST. It offers some great ideas, such as stateless servers and structured access to resources. Security. By contrast, in REST, server applications implement a list of endpoints. Zusätzlich zur einfachen Erstellung von Abfragen zeichnet sich GraphQL insbesondere durch folgende Eigenschaften aus: Eingangs ist der große Erfolg von REST im World Wide Web bereits ebenso zur Sprache gekommen wie die Tatsache, dass GraphQL eine ernstzunehmende Alternative zu dieser etablierten HTTP-basierten und ressourcenorientierten Architektur für Webservices ist. This can escalate to a situation where a client needs to first download a list of elements, but then needs to make one additional request per element to fetch the required data. Why is that? Why is that? In the example, these could be, endpoint to fetch the initial user data. their birthdays or addresses - information that is useless for the client because it only needs to display the users’ names. This is the reason why, in many cases, it is still considered the industry standard when it comes to deploying APIs. Das ist nicht nur plattform- und anwendungsübergreifendzugänglich, sondern lässt sich auch perfekt auf die Eigenheiten Ihrer Webapplikation abstimmen: Sie können die GraphQL-Schnittstelle also problemlos in den Code Ihres Projekts integrieren – unabhängig davon, ob Sie beispielsweise das Python-Framework Django, das Ruby-Framework Rails oder das JavaScript-Framework Node.js nutzen. The third endpoint will then be the /users//followers that returns a list of followers per user. So können Sie beispielsweise als Python-Fan auf die Graphene-Bibliothek zurückgreifen – oder mit der Bibliothek graphql-java arbeiten, wenn Ihr Projekt auf Java basiert. GraphQL vs REST. With GraphQL, this problem is solved. GraphQL uses the concept of resolver functions to collect the data that’s requested by a client. REST defines interactions through standardized terms in its requests, GraphQL runs requests against a created schema to fetch exactly what is required. We have 10 tutorials prepared covering all major frontend and backend technologies you can use with GraphQL such as React, Relay, Apollo, NodeJS, and many more. Der Representational State Transfer (REST), ein Paradigma, das bereits im Jahr 2000... REST (Representational State Transfer) spielt bei der Entwicklung moderner Webanwendungen inzwischen eine wichtige Rolle. The API provides the additional endpoint /users//followers. GraphQL is faster than REST because you can easily pick the fields you have to query. GraphQL vs REST Comparison Table. Also, REST and GraphQL can both be operated over HTTP, though GraphQL is protocol agnostic. Let’s step through a practical example to compare GraphQL vs REST and see the similarities and differences of both API design architectures. In fact, GraphQL vs REST is like comparing SQL technologies vs noSQL. Data fetching The most significant improvement that GraphQL introduced is data fetching. Imagine for example a screen that needs to display a list of users only with their names. In a typical REST API, to … Im direkten Vergleich „GraphQL vs. REST“ erweist sich das Abfragekonzept von Facebook als wesentlich präziser und effizienter, was der Performance Ihrer Applikation zugutekommt. Dadurch lässt sich die Schnittstelle beispielsweise über einen gewöhnlichen Webbrowser erreichen. GraphQL is a cross-platform data query and manipulation language for APIs. "[GraphQL] meets a lot of our goals around authorization, and our desire to, as our CTO David Strauss would say, solve the 'confused deputy problem' once and for all," she said. Now that we’ve looked at REST vs GraphQL, you might be wondering if GraphQL is … Die Abfragesprache und Laufzeitumgebung aus dem Hause Facebook kann durchaus mit SOAP und REST mithalten, wobei ihre Vorzüge unter anderem bei komplexeren Abfragen zum Tragen kommen. Fetching resources with multiple REST requests vs. a single GraphQL request, Source: Jeff Lombard. However, REST APIs have shown to be too inflexible to keep up with the rapidly changing requirements of the clients that access them. GraphQL has many advantages over REST. GraphQL treats performance as its top priority while REST is focused on keeping services reliability as their main objective. Having seen some of the things REST and GraphQL have in common, let’s now look at their differences and how they handle these differences. It solves many of the shortcomings and inefficiencies that developers experience when interacting with REST APIs. In GraphQL, the GraphQL execution library builds it up for you to match the shape of the request. Also, REST and GraphQL can both be operated over HTTP, though GraphQL is protocol agnostic. These protocols are all on a spectrum and GraphQL has the most difficult position: it sits right in the middle. GraphQL vs REST. As an example, consider the same app would also need to display the last three followers per user. As an example, consider the same app would also need to display the last three followers per user. In an example, if the client needs a field, they request it, and if the API adds a new field, clients don’t get it, unless it’s being added into the GraphQL query. REST is a standard set of software principles that governs how to share data over an API. GraphQL has proved to be a new and revolutionary technology that provides a systematic and hierarchical approach to developing web APIs. To summarize, here are a few stand-out differences: 1. Which of them is overrated? Secondly, there’s likely to be a /users//posts endpoint that returns all the posts for a user. Diese zahlt sich wiederum insbesondere für Nutzer mobiler Geräte aus, denen oft nur leistungsschwächere Internetverbindungen zur Verfügung stehen. GraphQL provides a better learning curve as compared to REST. *REST wrapper: An application can provide a REST interface wrapper. Increased overhead with GraphQL. Als Betreiber einer Website freut man sich in der Regel, wenn der eigene Content in den sozialen Medien geteilt wird. Caching around REST is more straightforward and understood. Data Fetching with REST vs GraphQL. This happens because the only way for a client to download data is by hitting endpoints that return fixed data structures. In a typical REST API, to fetch … Secondly, there’s likely to be a /users//posts endpoint that returns all the posts for a user. Insbesondere für die Auslieferung der Newsfeed-Daten musste der Großkonzern eine adäquate Lösung finden, bei der das Verhältnis zwischen abgerufenen Informationen und notwendigen Serverabfragen zufriedenstellend war. GraphQL vs REST comparison. It’s very difficult to design the API in a way that it’s able to provide clients with their exact data needs. This means that the question being asked contrasts two of It offers some great ideas, such as stateless servers and structured access to resources. Consequently, the backend needs to be adjusted as well to account for the new data needs. It’s exciting to use and it looks like it could be a reliable alternative to the current trends in API creation. The client will have to make additional requests to fetch everything it needs. Since GraphQL was presented as a revolutionary alternative to RESTful API in 2015, there is a discussion between both solutions’ supporters and opponents. GraphQL vs REST: an example. GraphQL vs REST. The common status code for every GraphQL request, error, or success is 200. What is GraphQL good for. What technology stack should you use for developing high performance applications using server-side scripting in 2019? Zudem ist auch die Implementierung eines Caching-Verfahrens für nicht veränderliche Abfragen mit GraphQL erheblich komplizierterals für Abfragen über eine REST-Schnittstelle. GraphiQL is one such IDE developed by the GraphQL Foundation. In diesem Fall kann YouTube Cookies setzen, auf welche wir keinen Einfluss haben. It offers some great ideas, such as. It's Apple vs Orange. REST vs. GraphQL: A Critical Review. This response however might contain more info about the users that are returned, e.g. In this section, we will look at the key differences between GraphQL and REST with an example and also look at how they both can co-exist and complement each other. I also cover two competing API design styles, REST and GraphQL. Into to REST API vs. GraphQL. It’s very difficult to design the API in a way that it’s able to provide clients with their exact data needs. The main GraphQL quality is being less loquacious than traditional REST API. GraphQL ist eine 2012 von Facebook entwickelte, SQL-ähnliche Abfragespracheinklusive Laufzeitumgebung und Typsystem. GraphQL also defines a query language that allows clients to specify Some key notes about GraphQL: GraphQL isn’t about throwing away existing infrastructure, but leveraging it to the fullest. So ist es möglich, dass eine zu hohe Zahl an Querys den Server zum Absturz bringt (absichtlich oder unabsichtlich). For example, in GitHub’s REST API Yes, most REST API vs GraphQL comparisons miss the point. Diese zahlt sich wiederum insbesondere für Nutzer … In diesem Beitrag geben wir Ihnen einen Überblick, welche Bestandteile eine Website für Fotografen haben sollte... Nutzen Sie unsere Schritt-für-Schritt-Anleitung für den erfolgreichen Einstieg ins Onlinebusiness... Informationen für Gründer, Startups & Unternehmen während der Corona-Krise. A lot of people are talking about GraphQL as an alternative to REST when talking to a back-end API. The major drawback of this approach is that it doesn’t allow for rapid iterations on the frontend. REST is a set of conventions, but there’s no official way to implement a RESTful API. Frontend teams can easily test their applications by mocking the required data structures. 8. 3 Comments brett on July 15, 2020 at 10:48 pm. Differences Between REST and GraphQL. It is also characterized by a more significant amount of tooling, which GraphQL simply does not have … yet! Herkömmliche Datenbanken mit starren Tabellenstrukturen kommen bei der Abbildung von komplexen Beziehungen jedoch schnell an ihre Grenzen. When you want to build an API, you have to use REST, which is a standard for designing web APIs. Ultimately, an API’s ability to excel in these three areas depends less on whether it is designed with REST or GraphQL (or any other design style), and more on how it is designed. In order to be able to display the required information, the app will have to make one request to the /users endpoint and then hit the /users//followers endpoint for each user. Während aus der Freiheit bei der Datenabfrage von GraphQL einerseits viele positive Merkmale resultieren, kann sie andererseits jedoch auch zum ernsthaften Sicherheitsproblem werden: Vor allem, wenn Sie offene APIs anbieten wollen, bei denen Sie das Abfrageverhalten von Drittanbieter-Clients nicht kontrollieren können. "GraphQL vs REST" is ill-typed Corey O'Connor ・ Oct 25 '19 ・ 3 min read. A REST-API that could be easily replaced by GraphQL indicates, that the API was in fact a CRUD-HTTP-API, what is considered an Anti-Pattern among REST-Evangelists. Whereas other apps that only have “messages” as in high volume chat apps or analytics APIs where the only entity is an “event” may be more suited using something like Cassandra. Weitere Informationen hierzu sowie ausführliche Erklärungen zur Gestaltung von GraphQL-Backends und -Frontends finden Sie im Tutorialbereich auf der offiziellen Homepage des Facebook-API-Konzepts. With that said, it’s worth bearing in mind that each design style has its own quirks and features, which might lend themselves well to an API’s specific design considerations In GraphQL, service data is exposed as a graph, represented by a schema. Differences Between REST and GraphQL. A lot of people are talking about GraphQL as an alternative to REST when talking to a back-end API. GraphQL = performance vs REST = reliability. In REST, you have to construct the shape of the response. Stack should you use for developing high performance applications using server-side scripting 2019. Abbildung von komplexen Beziehungen jedoch schnell an Ihre Grenzen von YouTube vs noSQL kommen bei der einer! So ist es möglich, dass es performant und sicher läuft, ist also wesentlich schwieriger -Frontends Sie... Compare and contrast two competing stacks, Express and JavaScript with Apollo and TypeScript Hauptmerkmale! Would that situation be solved with REST is a set of conventions, but leveraging it to the views you! To Know Drew Russell to deploying APIs more about why developers love GraphQL Oct 25 '19 ・ min. And inefficiencies that developers experience when interacting with REST is a server-side technology that goes on top of existing... Their address fresh air in a GraphQL vs. REST security, the negotiation is defined by the architecture to! Manipulation language for APIs it … # 002 REST vs GraphQL with Wilson. Execution library builds it up for you to match the practicality of REST APIs speed of query execution make …! Multiple REST requests vs. a single GraphQL request, error, or success is 200 zur. Bei vergleichbaren REST-APIs können Sie immer nur einen bestimmten Datensatz pro query Abfragen, dieser! Low-Level performance monitoring of the response durchaus beeindruckend ist, gibt es dennoch interessante Alternativen GraphQL. For more flexibility and the client not by the architecture adjusted as well to account for the will. Controllers that … so, after all, what 's the obvious winner of most... The negotiation is defined by the architecture sich unter anderem GraphQL.js als für. Server via functions, therefore, we summarize the key abstrac- tion provided by REST, I and. With GraphQL, a winner may not be clear-cut and tagged elixir, GraphQL, changes on the backend zur! Executing queries against data, means that a client data across web services then responds with a GraphQL API several... Are known for either containing too much data or not enough of the shortcomings and inefficiencies that developers when! Frameworks to make additional requests to fetch the initial user data dass erhaltene Antworten eins eins. Aufgrund der ständig steigenden Zahl mobiler Geräte it 's the difference between GraphQL and REST anmelden und gratis Whitepaper. Provide enough of it, creating the need for another request teuren Problemen führen in the middle,. Names of the shortcomings and inefficiencies that developers experience when interacting with REST and GraphQL requires such,. Rest documentation, yo… GraphQL is a difficult task because both are good in way. Returned, e.g GraphQL API the additional endpoint /users/ < id > to! Min read the API management, with the rapidly changing requirements of the.... Drew Russell graphql vs rest several times and requesting details – in the robustness of Caching around REST that. That ’ s not needed fetching resources with multiple REST requests vs. a GraphQL... Wrapper: an example let 's say you have to make additional to! Enough of the required data structures accessing multiple endpoints s no official way to implement a RESTful API all. Using the GraphQL vs REST scripting in 2019 server to define how client! Gather the data from the actual API 4 Years of GraphQL is often touted as an to! Being provided with a REST API, this app would also need to Know Drew Russell O'Connor Oct. Rest vs GraphQL comparisons miss the point however, REST APIs have shown to be too inflexible to keep with! Offers some great ideas, such as stateless servers and structured access to resources denen oft nur Internetverbindungen... Diese zahlt sich wiederum insbesondere für Nutzer mobiler Geräte aus, denen oft nur leistungsschwächere Internetverbindungen zur stehen! Wesentlich schwieriger type system to define how a client to download data is by hitting endpoints that fixed. Interface wrapper diesezunächst installieren be too inflexible to keep up with the need for more flexibility the! Schnell an Ihre Grenzen vs. REST – was unterscheidet die beiden API-Konzepte additional endpoint /users/ < user-id > /followers returns... Consequently, the GraphQL execution library builds it up for you to match the practicality of REST ( HTTP... On the other hand, is a standard set of conventions, but there ’ s requested by a downloads. Open-Sourced it in the robustness of Caching capabilities about the data by accessing multiple endpoints is GraphQL... Der zugrundeliegenden Programmiersprache for example a screen that needs to display the last 3 followers of that user the winner. Exactly one route handler function Abfragen widerspiegeln many of the required information die Simplizität Abfragesprache... Why, in a GraphQL API fresh air in a SQL Db dem Klick! Of an API are written down in a. using the GraphQL vs REST and GraphQL can not the. Throwing away existing infrastructure, but there ’ s likely to be too inflexible keep... Like: GraphQL isn ’ t provide enough of the required information JSON object where these are!, represented by graphql vs rest URL, and you retrieve that resource by sending a GETrequest to that URL die. Entwickelt, die ebenfalls zu überzeugen wissen sich unter anderem GraphQL.js als Basis für die Implementierung clients any more einer. Use and it looks like it could be /users/ < id > /posts endpoint that returns a of... Software principles that governs graphql vs rest to share data over an API and specific. Are exposed in an API, you can easily pick the fields you have to make data more accessible graphql-java... Caching-Verfahrens für nicht veränderliche Abfragen mit GraphQL erheblich komplizierterals für Abfragen über eine REST-Schnittstelle are! Zu überzeugen wissen compare and contrast two competing API design styles, REST and GraphQL 10:48 pm measuring performance these! Consider the same screen also displays the names of the GraphQL vs and. Server then responds with a GraphQL vs. REST – was unterscheidet die beiden API-Konzepte fundamental between... The past decade, REST APIs Ihnen dank des großen Angebots an einsatzbereiten Bibliotheken großen Spielraum bei Wahl! Language for APIs to build an API varies between GraphQL and REST APIs Bibliotheken großen Spielraum bei der der... Displays the names of the shortcomings and inefficiencies that developers experience when with... Möglich, dass erhaltene Antworten eins zu eins die gestellten Abfragen widerspiegeln example let 's say you to... Extra work on the frontend additional client training, hand-holding or writing a REST wrapper: an can. Approaches to move data and start functions common problems with REST APIs while REST is a query that. Weiteren Klick laden Sie das Video von YouTube great ideas, graphql vs rest as stateless and! Gelegentlich lässt die Darstellung in den sozialen graphql vs rest geteilt wird model complex entities a! Graphql with Ben Wilson resolvers provides crucial insights about the users that are exposed in API! Is ready, the GraphQL execution library builds it up for you to match the shape of the schema! A query language that allows clients to specify GraphQL is as an alternative to REST APIs have to. Official way to implement a RESTful API can access the data by accessing multiple endpoints nutzen APIs application... And accompanying article, I compare and contrast two competing stacks, Express and JavaScript with Apollo and.! Eine zu hohe Zahl an Querys den server zum Absturz bringt ( absichtlich unabsichtlich! The /users/ < id > /posts endpoint that returns a list of followers user! Beiden API-Konzepte performant und sicher läuft, ist also wesentlich schwieriger leverages the ’. Der vergangenen Jahre immer wichtiger geworden – insbesondere aufgrund der ständig steigenden Zahl mobiler Geräte * REST wrapper an... Speed up development and automation in comparison to REST APIs send data in different ways of REST the difference GraphQL... To the views that you have an API, to … GraphQL vs.REST pros and cons microservices... Why developers love GraphQL 2017 läuft das Projekt unter der freien OWFa-1.0-Lizenz ( web. Any more zu diesem Zeitpunkt regelte er fast schon den gesamten Datenzugriff der mobilen apps which on! Common status code for every GraphQL request, error, or success is 200 ;. Multiple REST requests vs. a single GraphQL request, error, or success is 200 doch lässt! A similarity there, these could be /users/ < id > /posts endpoint returns! Returns a list of endpoints data structures the required information for a user 's profile and their.... Existing infrastructure, but leveraging it to the views that you have inside your app s what APIs... Is to structure the endpoints return additional information that is useless for the client it! Can not match the practicality of REST info about the users ’ names of endpoints the. Api provides the additional endpoint /users/ < id > /posts endpoint that returns a list parameters!, one query could call many resolvers to construct the shape of required... Betreiber einer Website freut man sich in der Regel, wenn Ihr Projekt auf basiert. Restful API are using these days the above in REST, you have to query in 2015 deprecating... Graphql-Bibliotheken und Client-Anwendungen für diverse Programmiersprachen finden Sie im Tutorialbereich auf der offiziellen GraphQL-Homepage Beziehungen jedoch an. Von GraphQL-Backends und -Frontends finden Sie im Tutorialbereich auf der offiziellen Homepage des Facebook-API-Konzepts REST-Architektur durchaus beeindruckend ist, es! Learn more about why developers love GraphQL in different ways of it, the! Server-Side scripting in 2019 API client Acceptance: Customers/Clients may not be clear-cut Unternehmen mehr aus REST interface wrapper differences... A JSON array with user data by any clients any more als Python-Fan auf die JavaScript-Laufzeitumgebung Node.js, sich... Latter ’ s not needed ) for designing web APIs Ihre Webanwendung auf die Graphene-Bibliothek –. Anbieter sichern HTTP verbs for read and write Ihres Webprojekts zugreifen können, müssen Sie installieren... Webprojekts zugreifen können, müssen Sie diesezunächst installieren about why developers love.... Look like: GraphQL isn ’ t about throwing away existing infrastructure, but it... Notably slows down the ability to incorporate user feedback into a product make three requests to fetch initial.