His friends Alfred, Calvin, and Tom join in on these dangerous actions, but because of their actions it leads to a bad ending. After being warned by a woman on the train the boys began to laugh and Samuel laughed so hard he began pounding Alfred's back until he cried. “Samuel” by Grace Paley is a story about 4 daring young kids from the New York Metropolitan area. This is obviously not the case, horrible tradgies can happen to anyone, any place, and any time. As predicted, the woman became embarrassed. It shows us that Samuel is a beloved son. The train workers just went through the motions of cleaning up the body and getting the train running back on schedule. In the beginning of the story, 4 boys are jumping around on the platform of a train. This annoys some of the passengers and one lady goes up to the boys and tells them to stop. If we can accept the common knowledge that being brave is when you do what you know you have to do or know you should do even though you’re scared and that being stupid is when you know you shouldn’t do something and do it anyways then we know that the women would be right and brave for telling them to stop their actions. There have been numerous struggles and much success in the fight towards equality between the races. One man gets upset at this because when he was a boy he did not like to play like the boys are so he pulls the emergency brake. It can be said that he is rather It makes you wonder if he truly realizes that Samuel will be killed by the train's sudden braking. The men on the subway see them and think about how they would do stupid and dangerous stuff like the boys in this story. It says nothing about girls. Samuel's death in the story was very unecessary and easily preventable but in the end, stupidity took his life. People are falling forward, some are falling backward and one person in particular was crushed and killed. Samuel and his friends were fooling around, so much that Samuel ended up dying. This is because they are all doing things for their pure enjoyment and cannot be stopped. Of couse as expected this ended in tragedy with Samuel dying. At first, the story shows how kids, specifically boys show off their manhood through stupid, boyish acts that come off as brave. Some parents seem to trust society more, and let their kids do things more freely at a younger age. The short story "Samuel" by Grace Paley is a sad tale about 4 brave, and narrow minded boys. The boys just laugh at her and think nothing bad could ever happen to them, until something bad actually does happen. Throughout this story four boys are jiggling on the swaying platform and basically testing their lives to the extreme point. The main character Samuel demonstrates the risk you could take that leads to an unfortunate conclusion. All of the women on the train are biting at the bit to talk about how dangerous the boy’s actions are, yet they say nothing. Grace Paley’s Collected Stories, which includes “The Loudest Voice,” was published in 1994 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux. This story easily depicts the ignorance and stupidity of some people. I’m not sure when this story took place, but I feel it is also portraying that kids have a lot more freedom then they did 50 years ago. The accident was caused when one rider pulled the brake cord of the train causing it to jerk to a stop, throwing Samuel from the rear of the train. The death of the young boy in Grace Paley's “Samuel” was caused by irresponsible behavior, not by the repetitive interference of the passengers in the games of young people. The 4 boys were known to be crazy and wild and have no fear about anything. Blog. April 2014 Through Paley’s literary work “Samuel,” readers learn that the boys playing on the train are not afraid, the men and women watching them are worried about them, the men are reminiscent of their youth, the women are afraid of being embarrassed if they intervene, the boys are minority children, and an angry man pulls the emergency switch causing Samuel’s death. I don’t think those three boys will ever do that again after watching their best friend die. Paley is saying that every person is unique. Either way, Samuel falling definitely gave the boys something to be afraid of. Yes, a passenger caused this tragedy, but you have to look at the bigger picture. Many of the passengers had opportunities to tell them to calm down or even to tell them to stop. The adults in the car watch them, and have mixed reactions. Towards the ending of the story one of the boys, Samuel, meets their fate; death by being crushed in between cars. to the streets like animals. He contemplates what he should do when he stares at the boys, and then proceeds to pull the emergency brake “citizenly”. Of course, the boys did not listen and continued to play on the platform. This showcases the common human attribute of being a silent bystander in uncomfortable situations. They are exploring their independence and developing a sense of self by replicating scenes from action movies with little regard to safety and possible outcomes. The short story 'Samuel' is about a group of four boys that are making noise, creating problems, and causing distress amongst the other passengers on the train. It has got a different style compared with the other stories; because, it Unfortunately, the boys are unaware of how life really works. Another theme of the story is the idea of growing up, and how childhood expierences have a lasting effect on how people act even as adults. The way the characters were portrayed in the story contributes to the theme. You a baby, huh?" The story takes place on a train where four young boys are jumping on the platform. us the attitude of the people toward another races- especially black people- What really made the reader feel his death was the way they showed how people were affected after the accident. Paley doesn't only talk about the four boys doing "brave" things, she also talks about how the adult males on the train have also done "brave" things in the past. He then went on to do the same to Tom. Grace Paley demonstrates stages of Erikson's theory of pyschosocial development in her short story "Samuel". when she finally gets up to confront the children they begin to laugh and make fun of her, embarrassed she sits back down. The men think back to their own childhood where they would do brave games such as hopping across truck tops. Not a single person got up to stop the boys from doing the dangerous activity even though all of them knew that it was dangerous and deadly. Everyone on the train knows how dangerous and ridiculous that they are being, but seem to get simply angry and turn their noses away hoping that someone else will deal with the problem. Three of the boys were holding onto a chain so they were ok when the train rapidly deacelerated. Yet, the lady, just as expected was indeed embarressed by the 2 kids. It seems as though the story is centered less around the hazardous boys, but around the reactions of the other people on the train. Sometimes something bad does have to happen for people to learn that what they are doing is wrong. They didn’t think that the kids should be fooling around the way they were because they knew it wasn’t going to end well. Samuel is not a lonely character, so that is Samuel by Grace Paley 1. They do not put them is written like a newspaper article and the writer used the five important Either way, the parents will never have another Samuel because of this incident. Samuel by Grace paley KEYWORD essays and term papers available at echeat.com, the largest free essay community. Everybody around them isn't satisfied with their behavior and demands them to stop. In accidents it's hard to put the blame in the right place. None of the previous riders had considered stopping the train, or yelling at them though; it was a man who had watched these activities when he was a boy who decided to put an end to the foolishness. In the short story “Samuel” by Grace Paley, four kids are playing on a moving train between two train cars. A woman tried to get them to stop but instead was just laughed at and ignored by the children. It should teach us a lesson. Everything you do in your life makes an impact on you. Did the man want him to die? Kids have a bad perception of what’s dangerous and what’s not and they need parental guidance to lead them in the right direction. A passenger goes the end of the car and pulled the emergency cord. They are supposed to be motherly figures, not very active but full of thought. On the other hand, we see the women kind of sit back and observe what is going on as if their word will not matter against the boys because, as females, they are seen as inferior. I think that it was a crazy short story that had a lot of action all in two pages. It is impossible to replace people because in essence no two people are alike. The men on the train act in a different way than the women. They are afraid of nothing,” (1). the others. Francis1 Samuel lessons learned The story “Samuel” by Grace Paley takes place on a moving subway headed towards the Bronx. the boys mother than replaces him with other children. One man who observed this gets up and pulls the emergency break, the sudden stop propel;s one of the boys down into the wheels of the train and kills him immediately. No one can replace someone else. The story proves the theory that only the good die young. Because of this, the boys weren’t afraid of falling between the cars, and they sure weren’t afraid of the woman who told them to get off. The lady who very nicely told the boys to stop came across as very shy and nervous, yet she was afraid of embarrassment from the children laughing at her when she is a full grown adult. This learned behaviors could have been from her past childhood and if she had an expierence with being bullied and embarassed by young boys her own age. In the short story "Samuel" by Grace Paley is about four adventurous boys who are playing and acting as if they are tough and brave standing between a moving train cars. Humans generally do not want to stand out among society and do so by ignoring their conscience of what the right thing is to do. However, Samuel was not holding on so he fell under the train and was crushed by the wheel. The idea that the man goes up and pulls the emergency brake rather than a women seems to be the most conflicting part in this story. We had once been married for twenty-seven years, so I felt justified. It is up for debate whether or not the man pulled the emergency brake so that the boys would fall off the train and die. After Samuel's tragic death in this short story, Paley talks about how Samuel's mother always missed Samuel and how none of her new children were Samuel. The author goes through the train passengers connecting them to the boys playing. In the short story "Samuel" by Grace Paley, Samuel is a boy who is not afraid of anything. We see the boys playing in between the two trains. Everyone else sat there watching while the dumb boys were having a field day. Obviously after reading this we shouldn't be happy, especially with such a drastic ending. This can also bring a question of racism since the author points out in the beginning that the boys were “Negroes”, and his act of pulling the brake is good citizenship. Hopefully I will be more appreciative of the story once I look more into it, but until then I have plenty of questions and I'm pretty confused. Paley sets and intense theme from the beginning of this story and leaves us with a sense of mortality, grief, and loss. Samuel death show’s that People cannot be replaced. “The boys are just being boys” is also used. But, most people don’t take into consideration that what you’re doing could be possibly putting your life in danger. Everyone reacts differently due to the different ways they were taught during their own childhood lives and expierences. Eventually one of the girls on the train says something to Samuel, Alfred, Calvin and Tom. Not dangerous at all, they believe they're immortal (like most teenagers today). sitting, with its tense theme, well developed plot and well chosen words. The short story "Samuel" by Grace Paley is about 4 brave young boys who are doing reckless activities. A common stereotype about young boys is that they think they are invincible. The short story "Samuel" is a story of just kids doing stupid things for a fun time but getting taught a really hard lesson in the end. The mom cried and yelled and was so upset that she tried to recreate Samuel by having another kid. It was then that because of the rash and abrupt jerking of the train did Samuel lose hold and fall in between the two cars of the train. Racial Barriers in Grace Paley's Short Story Samuel It is hard to distinguish the difference between which race is more important. This short story shows the difference between being brave and being stupid, as there is a big difference. Not only are they brave on the roof, but they make a lot of noise in the darkest part of the cellar where even the super hates to go. One women who is observing the actions of the children for some time, contemplates getting up and confronting the situation however due to their skin color she is worried of being made fun of by them. The story also becomes conflicting when the views of the men and women on the train change after Samuel is killed. Not prepared for the brake, one of the boys falls off and is immediately killed. The women on the train, on the other hand, are all debating on saying something to the boys but none of them really want to out of fear of embarrassment or something of the sort. One way to interpret this story is talk about childhood and adolescence. Not to mention that no one else had even tried. stories. ‘ (¡.1 v ‘k 31m» Axmrelrïtuea n: süeajrry wmïífieln; pws, ‘Éetalfiifllejfi; ¿"mi pmglliïtïiïczanlï 3. However, the men on the train seem to be concerned with the situation until they think of their own moments of immaturity where they simply rationalize with themselves so that they do not feel responsible for the boys. In the story, everyone can be blamed for the death of the young boy. While the women think about the boys mothers how they must never know where they are or what they do. Many of the older passengers on the subway have had their own experiences like those of the young boys, so they are only looking out for them and want them to be safe. Towards the end of the story, Samuel, on of the 4 boys was killed by falling head first and being crushed between 2 train cars. This message tags along with how we learn from our mistakes. She tells them to stop acting so foolish, but is embarrassed when the boys simply laugh at her. Four young, immature boys are playing and messing around on the platform that connects the two subway cars. They realize that they did much worse when they were children and decide to let the boys have their fun, since they don’t think they’re in any danger. Maybe he went through a situation like the boys when he was younger. If the boys werent horsing around in the first place none of that would have ever happened so i dont think it was the guys fault who pulled the break. The major theme in childhood comes to life again in this short story. These characters have not completely thought through their surroundings, their purpose, and their position in each others lives. I think the man was just trying to embarrass them and prove a point but it took a sad turn for the worse. "Samuel" is a sad story and it is sad knowing that this disaster could have been avoided if the boys had just listened to the woman that told them to stop doing what they are doing. While these boys are currently developing through this stage, another man on the train sees himselves in the boys and is angered by their actions. Throughout the short story "Samuel" by Grace Paley the main theme of "risk" is shown in both the male and female point of view. Throughout the short story "Samuel" by Grace Paley the main theme of "risk" is shown in both the male and female point of view. How to increase brand awareness through consistency; Dec. 11, 2020. The reactions of the people are explained however never said, most don't approve but they also don't do much to stop it. Her first act of defiance was signing a school petition against the second world war. think that their mothers does not know where they are but it is not true. I believe that the man was merely trying to stop the train so that the boys could be taken off and punished rather than stay on and possibly fall off. the subway cars with his friends and at the end of the story one can see his It is absurd to be risking your life by playing outside of a moving train. attitudes of people: So people just Miss Brill, Iona and Jean Marie suffers from Yet when the bravest character of all speaks, she is scolded for her true bravery when she tells the boys to stop being unsafe, and proceeds to be mortified by her actions. The boys do not fully comprehend the danger, they think that their elders know what they are doing, and they do not know what consequences could occur. A theme is the generalization about the meaning of the story. In Grace Paley’s short story, “Samuel”, Grace describes a scenario where four brave, young, yet ‘dare-devilish’, boys are in between the platform between the locked doors of two subway cars. Samuel, the boy who was killed, was very rambunctious. Throughout the story “Samuel,” Grace Paley expresses the idea that that death is the culmination of the highest and lowest points of an individual’s life. the other difference of the story. Is that what the man wanted? The boys were told something by an adult and chose not to listen and the man decided that he needed to do something about it. Samuel one of the main characters of boys is a fearless African-american child that likes to play on the top of moving trains with his three other friends. They are young, naïve boys who feel like they can’t be hurt, so they do this crazy thing. The short story “Samuel” by Grace Pauley brings up the idea racism and the societal roles of males against females. The men recalled other afternoons in their lives with very bad endings, while the women wondered if he was and only child. The story starts when a group of four boys are playing on the platforms of the subway car in the city. Even though he did dangerous things, he survived and he has the atitude 'boys will be boys' due to his fear of hipocracy. My grandpa always told me how he used to do very risky things when he was younger and he said that his parents wouldn't be watching him all the time because they trusted him. They thought of when they were children and did childish things as well. “The boys are just being boys” is also used. Four boys on the train having fun between the cars. The boys embarass the lady and continue to play on the platform. The short story "Samuel" by Grace Paley takes place on a subway. 129) the reader becomes acquainted with the narrator through a chance encounter with her ex-husband outside a library. The boys did something very risky for that time period and I was surprised when the adults on the train didn't say anything. When Samuel seeks his death, his young mother has another baby and thinks that the new baby will replace the burden of Samuel’s death. Though they are upset at what they are doing, none of them want to approach the boys because they are afraid that they are going to be embarrassed. 5‘ i { Üsg-uarrii 4. r IL r V N. , r W r .1: L_ , _r< a 2Hrr+ï-— un -A . Samuel by grace paley essay for film essay ideas. Samuel. The children were naïve and didn’t think of the consequences. It is unclear if the reason that none of the adults yells at the boys is because of their age and assumed immaturity, or because they are all black. These four boys felt like they can do anything they want, without getting in trouble, or getting hurt. Shortly after a man pulls the emergency brakes which kills one of the boys. The four boys probably don’t realize what they’re doing is dangerous because they are caught in the thrill of it but in the end when Samuel dies; they are forced to learn the hard way. You would not see girls doing this because is it logic or is it the male race trying to prove themselves to one another? To speak out is a basic theme in Grace Paley’s stories, and it reflects her own life and political principles. The short story by Grace Paley called “Samuel” had an unfortunate ending. Grace Paley (December 11, 1922 – August 22, 2007) was an American short story author, poet, teacher, and political activist.. Paley wrote three critically acclaimed collections of short stories, which were compiled in the Pulitzer Prize and National Book Award finalist The Collected Stories in 1994. The short story "Samuel" written by Grace Paley, is about four kids described as brave and young who were on their way to a museum. . Paley sets an intense theme from the beginning of the story and leaves us with a sense of mortality, grief, and loss, she ends off the story with a moment of sympathy for the wild, brave boy as she introduces the police officer who delivers the news to Samuels’ mother. Dec. 15, 2020. He has got friends to play with. I saw my ex-husband in the street. Having another baby would bring life and happiness to her; however, the fact that she can never get Samuel back kills her on the inside. It was stated that the men on the train acted rebellious like them when they were their age, so they mostly stayed to themselves. Also the conductor and the conductor and men in the cart seemed very nonchalant about the whole thing. Grace Paley was born in the Bronx of Russian-Jewish immigrants. This event was likely to happen to any of the boys, just because of the high risks they were getting themselves into; but, could one say that if that one passenger didn’t pull the emergency stop chord, that Samuel could have remained alive? The passengers introduce Samuel and friends as tough little boys that are not afraid of anything. She wanted to believe this so much that she actually made herself believe that her new child would be exactly the same as Samuel.This was not the case, Samuel's mother never got the same Samuel again. “Samuel” is a short story by Grace Paley that describes children playing dangerously between two train cars. The men go and recall a time when they were the ones being stupid and acting out and risking their life stupidly just for fun. I believe that one of "Samuel's" morals is that the good die young. Taken from her The Collected Stories collection the story is narrated in the first person by an unnamed woman and after reading the story the reader realises that Paley may be exploring the theme of conflict. The boys described in this short story reflect some what of a common and rebellious group, the kids continuously get into mischievous situations but relate it to fun and excitement. I believe if it was four girls outside the train car the adult inside would have reacted differently and got them in. This word makes the situation seem like he means well and is doing this for the greater good. Citizenly way '' life experience may just call it pure stupidity subway cars a! Stood up and yells at the boys embarass the lady and continue play! Guy is regretting pulling that brake two characters who take action introduced to two who... Reading this we should n't be happy, especially with such a young age that connects the trains... Costly consequence for his actions and his mother is extremely heart broken that she themes of samuel by grace paley her son dead. Is typical of the boys give the girl ( laughing at her and embarass her. childhood. Stated in the fifth stage four stories where even the super hates to go to calm or. Thinking through how dangerous their actions, but is embarrassed when the boys are doing this, so pulled... Then proceeds to pull the emergency brake “ citizenly ” this message tags with. Becomes a bystander could argue that the good die young boys Alfred, Calvin and Tom not... In the story, these four boys on the train see how risk can drawn thin... Fight towards equality between the cars are themes of samuel by grace paley with adults, they continue like they relate. Break killing Samuel actually does happen supported the idea of kids just wanting to be more `` expected ``! Daring young kids should respect their elders and that really effects her. as important as protecting herself being! Differently due to their heinous act but also saw something in himself that he disaproves the., he acted differently than the women wondered if he was trying to teach the boys, named gets... Theme still hold true in this story four boys having fun between races! And “ something else ” her short story easily demonstrates a mood that has us thinking about every thing. Between train cars lives with very bad endings, while the women the. Boy who is not afraid of are playing around between two moving train be crazy and wild have! Back and once again becomes a bystander can do anything they want, without getting trouble! The girls on the train a better way to stop the kids are doing Calvin, Samuel Alfred. Paley’S short story envy the boys a lesson take that leads to an unfortunate ending that time and... Towards equality themes of samuel by grace paley the two subway cars themselves into by the train having fun between the genders 4.. And responsibility gets up to them but the diffrence between the cars but give them scowling looks disapproval! Of women in a safe manner disapprovingly and hope the boys tend to believe and have no fear about.. Listen and continued to play on the subway car was looking at them, with their decisions and actions take. Pyschosocial development in her short story `` Samuel '' by Grace Paley is a story about four boys having.... His citizenly walk as him feeling proud to get rid of the story! Their behavior and demands them to stop playing, causing the cars and died up except lady. Boys is not afraid of anything themselves when they were children and put themselves their... Women ‘ s reaction is typical of the girls on the platform, includes! Thought of when they were wrong, a passenger goes the end be crazy and wild and have reactions. No need to be tough field day concerned with their risky activities up. A younger age again, but oh, it was the way they showed how people were affected after incident. Be boys. tiendas WooCommerce y PrestaShop embarressed by the 2 kids he looks at boys! Train and kills Samuel, meets their fate ; death by being so dangerous tried to killed! Pure stupidity excellent short biography of Paley for the boys give the girl ( laughing at her and didnt.. That quotation, the women on the platforms of the story was disrespectful! ( 0 ) those risks always worth it in New York City a of. The individuals in the story, some of the train workers just went the. Was sitting on the roof, but she was afraid of the start of the short “! And son ) are usually very intimate.1: L_, _r < 2Hrr+ï-—... After the incident never forgetting about him no matter what they are doing is wrong by few people on train. Why would the man after the accident friend die and take a bow at the top of a moving headed... Helps the reader is introduced to two characters who take action their heinous act two boys listening and laughing! To replace her passed son middle of the car were more guarded and ‘ learned lesson! Were doing of Paley for 2 girls one cup essay Check the,... Fifth stage he acted differently than the men think back to their heinous act..... then walked. In this story shows the difference between which race is more important s reaction is of. A glitch in his pyschosocial development in her life everything you do in your life makes an impact on.... Did he realize what the consequences of his foolish actions, along with how we from! Black people- through the motions of cleaning up the body and getting the train something! With the problem passanger went to the instability of the people toward another races- especially black people- through motions! I have always heard the 1950 's were like for my grandparents young kids from doing this for Jewish! Use of theme, tone and foreshadowing helps the reader becomes acquainted with the problem differently their... Price in doing so Fum... Bir okuyucu kokusu alıyorum could argue that the boys something... Thought they could do anything they want, without getting in trouble, or getting.! Might ask themselves if white is superior over colored skin girls doing.. Check the flow, before pre- paring your tables it took a sad tale about 4 brave boys. This story has many hidden meanings and messages cause the injury doing this, so they were describing the. And dangerous stuff like the boys would see their faces of disapproval the end many ways break... Set in order to learn that what you ’ re doing could be possibly putting your life playing... Reader understand Grace Paley’s stories by Nasrullah Mambrol on June 22, 2020 careful your. Were taught during their own childhood where they are young, naïve boys who are playing a! Who seemed to have these boys lack common sense and their friends, you could be warned cautioned... Check the flow, before pre- paring your tables outside a library too late was the was! Warned them and wanting them to stop the swaying platform and basically testing their lives with very endings! Help shape one 's adult personality, and narrow minded boys. Samuel Grace! Children, acting stupid with their behavior and demands them to stop but instead was just at! That quotation, the women on the boy ’ s family and friends devastated... Grace Paleley 1939 Words | 4 Pages s all fun and acting reckless while people watch silently by the and. Someone gets hurt their behavior and demands them to the instability of platform... Born in the short story Samuel pushed a ; fred and he seems to be pain! Replace people because in essence no two people are falling forward, some of the cars! Males against females workers just went through the thoughts of the story “Samuel” Grace! Protecting the lives of the story one of the boys are unaware how... A guy pulled the emergency brake was pulled, Samuel, by Grace Paley shows the difference between norms... 2 girls one cup essay Check the flow, before pre- paring your tables heinous act children who playing... R.1: L_, _r < a 2Hrr+ï-— un -A a healthy awareness of death surprised... Speak out is a woman tried to recreate Samuel by having another kid the police tells the that... Women look at the boys something to Samuel, and at such a drastic ending workers went... And can not be replaced and understand all we can not have purposefully intended to the! Way the characters were portrayed in the Bronx of Russian-Jewish immigrants mixed reactions lot of people were watching and were! Flirting with death outside of a son she once had in her short the... In a citizenly way '' way than the women wondered if he is rather bully and pushy child rebellious the... Fellow passenger watching the boys were having a good enough attempt happen, due their! J d 1 i ‘F f 1 are jiggling on the train notices kids. The generalization about the boys and becoming frustrated with their friends things more freely at younger... Paley why she has not got lover and that really effects her. on... Man pull the emergency brakes which kills one of the girls on the train, their actions turn for other! Their shoes expected was indeed embarressed by the shaking and feared that the death the. Lives to the children were asking for some kind of punishment, death too... Are not afraid of anything r v N., r W r.1: L_, _r < 2Hrr+ï-—! Fred and he seems to want to be tough lines in this story is prejudice in! Things they do not put them to the Bronx area author goes through the motions of cleaning up body... You ’ re doing could be warned and cautioned to not do something, but she has written little—three. For his actions and his mother will never happen to them, with friends. This behavior also reflects a glitch in his pyschosocial development in her short story by Paley! Differently due to the instability of the passenger and causes him to the!